Eggs Benedict – The Breakfast Food of Champions

I strongly believe that the greatest example of human advancement is breakfast foods. A controversial statement, I know. For those who would argue that advances in technology, infrastructure and medical research are more worthy candidates for this honour – I’m afraid that you’re terribly misguided and need to spend some serious time reflecting on your life.

So, why am I of this opinion? Think about it – sweet AND savoury flavours are socially accepted norms at the breakfast table. You simply cannot beat that.

I’d have to say that my favourite breakfast concoction is Eggs Benedict. Why? Because I’m not a commy bastard, that’s why.

As per usual, there are conflicting accounts of how this magically delicious meal came to be. Here’s a couple of the more interesting ones:

The earliest account of the Benedict comes from the 1860s.  Credit is given to Delmonico’s Restaurant – the first restaurant/dining hall to be opened in the United States.  A regular patron of the restaurant, Mrs. LeGrand Benedict, was bored with the menu and asked the chef,  Charles Ranhofer, whether there was anything new he could cook for her. He suggested poached eggs on toasted English muffins with a thin slice of ham, topped with hollandaise sauce and a truffle.

I wish being a demanding bitch resulted in getting a delicious breakfast dish named after me. I suppose having a name such as ‘LeGrand’ would help.

Ranhofer went onto include a recipe for Eggs Benedict in a cookbook that he published in 1894. He called it ‘Eggs à la Benedick’, and had by this time removed the truffle from the list of ingredients.

The Lovely Katie took a photo of the delicious looking Eggs Benedict she had over the weekend. As you may notice it includes spinach. I knew I wasn’t crazy…

1894 seems to be intimately intertwined with the history of the Benedict, because it’s from this year that my favourite account of its creation hails. This story first appeared in an issue of the New Yorker from 1942, and was based on an interview with one Lemuel Benedict, a retired Wall Street broker.

Mr. Benedict claimed that he was dining at the The Waldorf one morning whilst suffering from a particularly nasty hangover. In order to combat his ailment he ordered “some buttered toast, crisp bacon, two poached eggs, and a hooker of hollandaise sauce” The Waldorf’s chef, Oscar Tschirky, was so impressed with this invention that he put the dish on his breakfast and luncheon menus. Are you at all surprised that the Benedict may have started out as a therapeutic hangover cure? Me either.

Meanwhile, I’m going to personally crusade to bring back the term ‘hooker’ as a name for crockery and containers.

“Honey, can you put the gravy hooker on the table?”

So kids, I have a bit of a confession to make. After many years of eating Eggs Bennie, I have only recently discovered that traditional recipes do not include spinach, despite the fact that I always seem to get it in restaurants. As many of you are probably aware, spinach is in fact a substitute for the ham or bacon, which renders the dish as Eggs Florentine. Despite the error of my ways, I stand firmly by the belief that the Benedict is greatly enhanced by the inclusion of spinach, and not just because it makes me strong like Popeye.

My discovery (and subsequent food-knowledge shame) inspired me to look up other variations of Eggs Benedict – and good lord are there a lot of them.  Enjoy the long and fascinating list!

  • Eggs Blackstone – adds a tomato slice. OUTRAGEOUS.
  • Eggs Florentine – As discussed,  substitutes spinach for the ham.
  • Eggs Mornay – Surprise, surprise, it substitutes the Hollandaise with Mornay sauce.
  • Eggs Atlantic or Eggs Hemingway – Substitutes salmon  for the ham. This is a common variation found in Australia, New Zealand and Canada. This variation can also be referred to as Eggs Royale or Eggs Montreal in New Zealand, and Eggs Benjamin in Canada. In Australia, I’ve only ever seen it referred to as  ‘Eggs Benedict with Salmon’. Yeah, we’re original like that.
  • Huevos Benedict – Substitutes either sliced avocado or chorizo for the ham, and is topped with both a salsa and hollandaise sauce.
  • Oeufs a la Benedictine – Replaces the ham with salted cod and the muffins with potatoes.
  • Eggs Hussarde – Substitutes Holland rusks (similar to melba toast) for the English muffin and adds Bordelaise sauce.
  • Eggs Sardou  – First served  in a New Orleans restaurant. Originally, it replaced the English muffin and ham with artichoke bottoms, topped with anchovy fillets.  On top of the egg and hollandaise sauce was a dollop of chopped ham and a slice of truffle. A more widespread version of the dish starts with a base of creamed spinach, substitutes artichoke bottoms for the English muffin, and eliminates the ham.
  • Artichoke Benedict – Replaces the English muffin with a hollowed artichoke.
  • Country Benedict – Replaces the English muffin, ham and hollandaise sauce with an American biscuit, sausage patties, and country gravy. The poached eggs are replaced with fried. This is also sometimes called Eggs Beauregard.
  • Irish Benedict –  Replaces the ham with corned beef.
  • Eggs à la Commodore – Poached eggs and béchamel sauce over pâté de foie gras purée spread on grilled buttered toast circles.
  • Portobello Benedict – Substitutes Portobello mushrooms for the ham. This is a popular alternative for Catholics observing the Friday Fast.
  • Eggs John Scott – Replaces the Hollandaise sauce with HP Sauce.
  • Eggs Maryland – Replaces the ham with crab cakes.
  • Waldorf Style Eggs – Replaces the English muffin with toast and is served with poached eggs, sautéed mushrooms and mushroom sauce.
  • Oscar Benedict – Replaces the ham with asparagus and crab meat. Also known as Eggs Oscar.
  • Eggs Billy – Replaces the English muffin with a lightly toasted buttermilk biscuit and the poached egg with fried.
  • Eggs Provençal – Replaces the Hollandaise sauce with Béarnaise Sauce.
  • Russian Easter Benedict –  Replaces the Hollandaise sauce with a lemon juice and mustard flavored Béchamel Sauce, and is topped with black caviar.

I’m willing to bet that there are an abundance of other variations out there. Do share if you have stumbled across any others!

23 thoughts on “Eggs Benedict – The Breakfast Food of Champions

  1. “I’m afraid that you’re terribly misguided and need to spend some serious time reflecting on your life.” OH GOD WHATS WRONG WITH ME!!!!! oh and also i really want some eggs now.. 😛 thanks

  2. Where, prithee tell, can I find me some Irish Benedict? That sounds incredible.

    Also love the idea of Oeufs a la Benedictine for the potatoes, but will stick with ham rather than salted cod. And it shall be known as Eggs Bethedict. Splendid.

  3. Fun fact: Hollandaise sauce is reeeaaally easy to make with a blender (although clarifying the butter is still a little fiddly). Were you ever there when I made it at casa del Auburn St?

  4. California Benedict (from a breakfast joint I used to frequent): Tomato AND Avocado instead of ham! It’s ‘outrageously’ good!

    Another type of California Benedict: Carne Asada, tomato and avocado.

    Now I want some eggs Benedict. Breakfast for dinner? I think I shall.

    • Mmm, adding avocado to anything is a good idea in my book. Including cakes, chocolate and smoothies. Seriously.

      Personally, I would add the avocado and tomato, whilst also keeping the bacon and therefore having ALL THE DELICIOUSNESS!!!


  5. PJD hates eggs, CIA loves them; the weird thing is that PJD cooks great eggs. Now I just have to learn to make Hollandaise sauce and stop talking about myself in the third person. I like the sound of Huevos Benedict, if only for the literal sound of the words…


Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s